Man fined after his Alsatians attacked and killed sheep on Mayo commonage

A judge has warned of the impact of dog worrying upon farmers and livestock after two Alsatians attacked and killed sheep on an Achill commonage.

Mark Kulendrai, Sion Hill, Castlebar pleaded guilty at Achill District Court to offences under the Control of Dogs Act, including worrying of livestock, failing to keep a dog securely muzzled and failing to keep the dog on a chain or leash.

Sergeant John Reilly told the court that Kulendrai was walking his two Alsatian dogs on a leash in the Keel Sandybanks area of Achill on August 7, 2024.

It is a popular walking location which also serves as a commonage for local farmers. A hare came into view and the dogs got away from Kulendrai and bolted across the commonage.

The dogs attacked four ewes belonging to a local farmer Martin Calvey.

Two were killed and the other two suffered injuries.

Sergeant Reilly said the incident was observed by two independent witnesses.

The total cost of damages to Mr. Calvey for his livestock, the removal of the carcasses and vet bills came to €1,044.40.

A victim impact statement prepared by Mr. Calvey was presented to Judge Mary McAveety.

Compensation of €1,050 had been previously paid by the defendant, who has no previous convictions.

Solicitor Gary Mulchrone said his client works as a carer and has a home in Achill.

Kulendrai has owned the dogs for six years and had no other issue with them. When the dogs got away, the defendant fell and injured his knee, later requiring surgery.

Mr Mulchrone said Kulendrai was very sorry about what had happened and now no longer brings the two dogs out together, walking them separately.

Judge McAveety said she would not be willing to apply the Probation Act in this case and stressed the seriousness of what had occurred and the impact it had on Mr. Calvey.

“It is lucky this occurred in August and not in the springtime during lambing season. I am acutely aware of the impact dog worrying has on farmers, it goes beyond damages,” she said.

Judge McAveety imposed a fine of €500.

* Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme.